Rowing in unison to enhance crossborder payments

Victoria Cleland is the Executive Director for Banking, Payments and Innovation at the Bank of England

The importance of crossborder payments

I have previously highlighted the establishment of the G20 roadmap and targets to enhance crossborder payments. I want to update you on some of the tangible progress already made in this area, and to stress the important role that working collaboratively across the public and private sectors to deliver real improvements to the cost, speed, transparency and accessibility of crossborder payments.

Crossborder payments are essential to the global economy. It is estimated that this year the global crossborder payment market will settle $156 trillion1. And it is not just the wholesale markets that are impacted: crossborder payments are crucial to businesses, consumers and remittances. In Greece alone remittances reached an all-time high of 338 EUR million in January 20222.

And the importance of crossborder payments is due to grow further. Business-to-business crossborder payments grew over 25% over the past two years and reached $34 trillion in 20213. A recent study suggested that 87% of global merchant executives see crossborder sales as their biggest growth potential4.

But despite their importance, many crossborder payments are still slow, expensive and difficult to track. While some wholesale payments are very effective, there are too many cases, for remittance payments in particular, where payments can take up to 10 days and cost more than 10% of the value of the underlying transfer. And this has a very real impact on businesses and individuals.

This underlines why enhancing crossborder payments is so critical and why the G20 made it a priority in 2020. To recap briefly, the first step was a Financial Stability Board (FSB), report assessing the frictions and challenges5. The Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures (CPMI) then set out the building blocks that would be instrumental in addressing the challenges6.

And in October 2020 the FSB coordinating with CPMI and other standard setting bodies, published a roadmap – a high-level plan of the timelines, actions and actors required to progress each building block7.

The roadmap consists of 19 building blocks that were arranged into 5 focus areas (see Figure 1). The first 4 focus areas seek to enhance the existing payments ecosystem by, for example, coordinating regulatory, supervisory and oversight frameworks; improving existing payment infrastructures; and increasing data quality.

Figure 1. The 19 building blocks and 5 focus areas of the G20 roadmap

The fifth focus area is more exploratory and covers emerging payment infrastructures and arrangements including Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs).

In October 2021, following a public consultation, the FSB announced clear quantitative global targets to address the 4 challenges of crossborder payments – cost, speed, access and transparency across 3 market segments – wholesale, retail and remittances – the majority of which will come into effect in 20278. Work is underway to assess how to measure progress against the targets. And crucially work is underway to enable the targets to be met.

To achieve the magnitude of change needed at pace will require collaborative effort.

I wanted to bring collaboration to life with an example from Greece – the Trireme. This famous ship – the fastest in the ancient world9 – derives its name from its three tiers of oars, and its success has been attributed to the collaborative efforts of these three tiers working together. This ship and its ethos of teamwork provide a key metaphor for how we can successfully bring about change in how crossborder payments work.

In the world of crossborder payments the three key groups are: central banks, industry and public authorities. There is a saying “If you want to go fast, go alone. If you want to go far, go together.” We need to go far together to reach the FSB targets on cost, speed, access and transparency.

Progress so far

The G20 roadmap on crossborder payments is now well into its second year. Considerable progress has been made meeting the actions and developing a strong understanding of the issues and publishing best practice and guidance.

There has also been tangible progress towards the desired outcomes. I will mention a few examples from the CPMI led building blocks, to whet your appetite, but should stress that this is not an exhaustive list.

  • Building block 9: The CPMI received multiple responses to its October 2021 call for ideas on expanding payment-versus-payment for FX transactions. These responses have helped inform a consultative report that will be published in the summer.
  • Building block 10: The Reserve Bank of Australia is working towards expanding access to domestic payment systems for non-bank payment service providers (PSPs)10. And the Central Bank of India has reviewed access criteria in 2021 and expanded access to certain categories of non-bank payment system operators11.
  • Building block 12: The US Fed has extended Fedwire operating hours in 2021, it is now operational for 22 hours per day, 5 days per week12. The European Central Bank is planning to extend operating hours as part of the go-live of the consolidation project in November 2022.
  • Building block 13: In May 2022 Sveriges Riksbank and TIPS have established a connection with the goal to use TIPS services to settle non-euro currencies in central bank money13.
  • Building block 14: The European Central Bank is migrating to ISO in Real-time Gross Settlement (RTGS) payments in November 202214, with the Bank of Japan having already migrated to ISO and completing version upgrade in 2025.

To support further progress, in May 2022, the CPMI published reports on expanding access and extending operating hours15. These relate to two foundational building blocks that can enable the progress of many other building blocks of the roadmap.

I want to discuss why these two reports are critical and how central banks, industry and public authorities can play a key part in advancing the roadmap.

Enhancing crossborder payments is crucial to the global economy; tangible progress is already being made; and to really change the dial we need work collaboratively

How improving direct access can enhance crossborder payments

The Building block 10 report assesses the benefits and risks of expanding access to domestic payment systems in particular RTGS systems. Expanded access could enable non-bank PSPs, financial market infrastructures (FMIs) and foreign banks to gain direct access to the payment systems they rely on to provide payment services to end-users, without relying on an intermediary (who maybe also be a competitor).

According to a CPMI survey, approximately 30% of the payment systems allow non-bank PSPs and FMIs direct access16 and 28% reported have made significant changes to their direct access policies since 2010. And despite the fact that the 61% of payment systems that are considering to expand access within the next 5 years, only 7% have concrete plans to do so.

Expanding access could have some clear benefits for crossborder payments:

  • Shorter transaction chains: expanding direct access to non-bank PSPs, FMIs and foreign banks will reduce the number of intermediaries involved in a crossborder transaction, thereby making payments quicker and more transparent.
  • Enhanced competition and lower cost: expanding access can level the playing field between banks and other PSPs and foster greater competition and innovation to give customers a greater choice of services and potentially lower prices.
  • Improved financial stability due to reduced tiering risk: the risk of spillovers of a direct participant’s default due to the transactions of indirect participants decreases.

These benefits needs to be balanced against risks such as additional counterparty credit risk and operational risk that central banks needs to be aware of and safeguard against when considering expanding access. The report discusses how these can be mitigated, for example setting minimum standards of resilience and security, and how to overcome potential barriers such as national legislation.

How extending RTGS operating hours across jurisdictions can help improve crossborder payments

The Building block 12 report examines RTGS operating hours. Limited RTGS operating hours across jurisdictions can lead to a delay in crossborder settlement, especially between countries with significant time zone differences.

The report identifies the current ‘global settlement window’, between 06:00 to 11:00 (UK time) when the highest number of RTGS systems across jurisdictions are concurrently open allowing crossborder transactions to settle across those jurisdictions without delays. The report highlights three possible end-states for an expansion of operating hours: (i) an incremental increase in operating hours on working days, (ii) an increase to include current non-operating days like weekends or holidays and (iii) extension to full 24/717.

Expanding operating hours would have some significant benefits for crossborder payments:

  • Faster crossborder payments: longer operating hours would extend the window of overlap between systems and lower an operational barrier to completing crossborder payments within the 1hr timeframe specified in the FSB targets.
  • Improved liquidity management: to enable crossborder payments banks need to hold liquidity positions to fund the payment. The longer crossborder payments take the longer these positions need to remain open, trapping liquidity. Greater overlap in operating hours could speed up the transaction.
  • Reduced settlement risk: when the operating hours of payment systems do not overlap final settlement in central bank money cannot happen which leads to the build-up on settlement risk. The longer settlement is delayed due to operating hours the greater the settlement risk becomes. Expanding operating hours will make crossborder payments faster and reduce settlement risk

But, as the report points out, there are also risks and operational and policy implications to assess when reviewing expansion of operating hours. Parties involved in RTGS systems may need to review and enhance existing operational procedures, risk monitoring tools and mitigation measures, and central banks and other authorities, will need to consider issues related to monetary policy, financial stability, and resolution policy for troubled institutions.

Undertaking the assessments of access and operating hours is critical

The reports encourage central banks and authorities to review the benefits, risks and barriers of expanding access and operating hours and set out a framework to do so.

The report on access sets out a holistic framework that central banks and authorities can follow and by providing real-world examples and case studies of jurisdictions that have successfully expanded access.

And the report on expanding operating hours encourages authorities to assess the three end-states and reviewing the opportunities, risks and policy implications for each of them.

While the reports say ‘encourage’, I would really urge central banks to undertake such reviews – the more that change, the greater our ability to meet the FSB global targets. With building blocks 10 and 12 being foundational for the roadmap, undertaking the assessments and taking action to expand access and operating hours will also have a direct positive impact across many building blocks.

The Bank of England’s renewed RTGS service

I want to bring this to life by outlining what the Bank of England will be doing in response to these two reports and how our RTGS Renewal Programme will support this work18.

The Bank is in the process of a multi-year project to renew RTGS. While changing our domestic infrastructure, this Programme also has an eye to opportunities to enhance crossborder payments.

There are two key milestones approaching: CHAPS payments will migrate to enhanced ISO 20022 messaging in April 2023, followed by the switchover of the core settlement engine in Spring 2024. The new RTGS platform will have the capability to extend operating hours to 22/5, and with further changes, to near 24/7 operation.

And it will be built with the capacity to accommodate a significant increase in account holders. Importantly, it will be a modular design with a strong foundation on which to build additional innovative functionality.

We are currently consulting industry on a menu of features which could be introduced to RTGS beyond 202419. This includes assessing demand for a number of features, including synchronised payments that seek to bring not only domestic benefits, but help to improve crossborder payments. The consultation closes in June 2022 and we expect to issue a response document around the end of this year.

In 2017, the Bank became one of the first central banks to expand access to non-bank PSPs. But we want to keep pace with the fast-changing payments landscape.

By spring 2023 line with roadmap timelines, we plan to review access arrangements by conducting a gap analysis to understand if we have expanded access to the three key groups identified in the report, and consider if we can do more to expand access.

And to a similar timeline we plan to undertake operational, risk and policy analysis to arrive on a way forward on operating hours.

Towards an international effort – central banks, industry and public authorities rowing in unison

In a highly connected and networked industry such as payments, we can only make a real difference if we work together in a coordinated way. We need to row together in unison to reach our destination of faster, cheaper, more transparent and more inclusive crossborder payment services.

So what are the concrete actions that each of the groups – central banks, industry and public authorities – need to take?

The role of central banks

Central banks, both as operators and supervisors, of payment infrastructure, we have a key role to play. We build infrastructure, add new functionality and set standards and policies to underpin safe and efficient economic and social activity.

Central banks need to start changing policies and enhancing core payment systems in line with the best practices, assessments and analysis that are developed as part of the work on the 19 building blocks.

To do so effectively, we need to listen to and collaborate with industry, involving them in outreach and consultations and updating them on latest developments.

And we also need to share our learnings and experiences with our peers, and beyond. This could be done through the establishment of communities of practice, through which central banks can discuss challenges and barriers with peers and find ways to overcome them.

The role of industry

The payments industry is another key, and wide range group including correspondent banks, FMIs and the non-bank fintech. Industry uses payment systems to provide payment services to customers, to innovate and develop new products for users. And industry can help central banks in undertaking the assessments of access and operating hours by collaborating, sharing insights and feeding into consultations and dialogue.

To meet the FSB targets there is also a practical role for the industry to respond to the building block actions and reports, with some requiring direct action. This might include:

(i) investing in new technologies,

(ii) preparing for changing operational procedures and

(iii) adapting business models.

The role of public authorities

And there is a crucial role for the wider public authorities. Central banks changing systems and policies and industry investing in changing operational procedures are just two pieces of the puzzle. There are also important regulatory, legislative and other barriers that overcome on a national and international level.

For example, finance ministries will need to prepare legislative change to deliver the benefits of the roadmap (eg. on AML/CFT standards, data frameworks and settlement finality protections). And international standard setting bodies will need to ensure that these standards are aligned on a global level.

The financial system is global, with many of the most important issues requiring the involvement of international public authorities. The FSB, CPMI, the BIS Innovation Hubs, and a range of other standard setting bodies will have a continued important role to play to reach the quantitative targets for cost, speed, access and transparency of crossborder payments.

They will need to enable best practice sharing between different jurisdictions, monitor the progress achieved on the roadmap and set out clearly what industry needs to do, and to explore what structures could achieve real change. The IMF and World Bank could also help by encouraging involvement and collaboration of non-CPMI countries and offering technical assistance.

Conclusion

I want to leave you with three key messages: enhancing crossborder payments is crucial to the global economy; tangible progress is already being made; and to really change the dial we need work collaboratively.

And ‘we’ means the three groups of stakeholders – central banks, industry and public authorities – working towards a common vision. The one difference to the Trireme is that there may be different starting points reflecting the nature of individual jurisdictions.

I look forward to continuing to work with you all on this important mission to enhance crossborder payments: collaboration will be the key to our success.

Endnotes

1. Cross-border Payments Outlook 2022: Trends, Challenges, and Opportunities.

2. Trading Economics: Remittances in Greece.

3. Juniper Research: Cross-border payments.

4. Visa Global Merchant eCommerce Study.

5. Enhancing Cross-border Payments – Stage 1 Report to the G20 (FSB Report 2020).

6. Enhancing Cross-border Payments – Stage 2 Report to the G20 – Building Blocks of a Global Roadmap (FSB Report 2020).

7. Enhancing Cross-border Payments – Stage 3 Roadmap (FSB Report 2020).

8. Targets for Addressing the Four Challenges of Cross-Border Payments (FSB Report October 2021).

9. Trireme – DK findout!

10. Speech: Real-time payments in Australia.

11. RBI to give some non-banks access to payments systems.

12. Expansion of operating hours and associated changes for the Fedwire  and Fedwire Funds Service.

13. Sweden completes first phase of migration to TIPS.

14. TARGET consolidation: Timeline.

15. Extending and aligning payment system operating hours for cross-border payments (CPMI Report May 2022) and Improving access to payment systems for cross-border payments: best-practices for self-assessments (CPMI Report May 2022).

16. Improving access to payment systems for cross-border payments: best-practices for self-assessments (CPMI Report May 2022).

17. Extending and aligning payment system operating hours for cross-border payments (CPMI Report May 2022).

18. RTGS Renewal Programme | Bank of England.

19. Roadmap for Real-Time Gross Settlement Service Beyond 2024.

I would like to thank Paul Bedford, Michaela Costello, Sophie Dalzell, John Jackson, Anna Koch and Karin Oldham for their help in preparing these remarks. This article is based on a speech delivered at the Central Bank Payments Conference 2022.